212: Is Renting Really Throwing Money Away? The Truth in 2025

Home SellingSelling Real EstateCalifornia Real EstateReal Estate InvestingHome Buying 101

Oct 6

Is Renting Really Throwing Money Away in 2025?

For years, the phrase “renting is just throwing money away” has been repeated like an undeniable truth. After all, when you pay rent, that money goes to your landlord and never comes back — no equity, no tax benefits, no long-term wealth. But here’s the thing: it’s not always that simple. In some situations, renting actually makes more financial sense than buying.

Renting vs. Buying: The Big Picture

Owning a home does come with clear long-term advantages. With a mortgage, you’re building equity over time, potentially enjoying tax benefits, and benefiting from appreciation. Homeownership has been a major driver of wealth in the U.S. — homeowners typically have a much higher net worth than renters, with recent data showing a median wealth gap of nearly $400,000 (and over $1.3 million on average).

But buying a home also comes with costs that often get overlooked: property taxes, insurance, maintenance, repairs, and transaction fees when you buy or sell. In contrast, renters avoid all of that and benefit from flexibility, especially if they need to move quickly or aren’t ready for the financial responsibility of homeownership.

What the Numbers Say in 2025

A 2025 Bankrate study showed that in all 50 of the largest U.S. metros, the average cost of buying a home was 38% higher than renting. In cities like San Francisco, San Jose, and Los Angeles, renting remains significantly more affordable month-to-month. For someone who only plans to stay a few years or needs financial flexibility, renting often comes out ahead.

On the other hand, long-term homeowners have historically gained tremendous equity. One analysis showed that owners gained $169,000 in equity over a certain period, while renters missed out on the same amount and effectively “lost” $229,000 by not owning.

Pros and Cons of Each

Renting Pros:

Lower upfront costs
Flexibility to move
No maintenance or repair bills
Avoid property taxes and insurance headaches

Renting Cons:

No equity or long-term investment
Paying into someone else’s wealth
Less stability with rent increases

Buying Pros:

Builds equity over time
Potential tax benefits
More stable payments with a fixed-rate mortgage
Long-term wealth building via home equity

Buying Cons:

High upfront costs (down payment, taxes, insurance)
Maintenance and repair expenses
Less flexibility if you need to move

When Renting Makes More Sense

High mortgage rates: When loan payments outpace rents, renting may save money.
Short-term living plans: Selling a home after just a year or two can eat up equity gains.
Uncertain job or income stability: Renting allows you to move without financial stress.
Low savings or high debt: Buying can add pressure when unexpected costs hit.
Better investment opportunities elsewhere: Sometimes investing outside of real estate yields higher returns.

The Bottom Line

Renting is not always throwing money away. It can be the smarter choice when you need flexibility, affordability, or more time to get financially ready for ownership. However, buying almost always pays off in the long run, building wealth and stability through home equity.

The real question isn’t whether renting or buying is “better.” It’s this: Which one makes the most sense for you, right now, given your financial situation and goals?

listen to the full episode

on your favorite podcast streamer below.

-> Apple

-> Spotify

______________________________________________________________________

Extra Real Estate with Soul Links you can’t miss!

Are you SUBSCRIBED to our YouTube Channel?

Subscribe at https://www.youtube.com/c/LoriAlvarez and tell us you did by messaging us on our

Felt inspired by this episode? Let us know! We'd love to hear from you by leaving our Podcast a review. And you just might get a special shout-out on the podcast! Thanks for choosing to spend your time with us!
Want more behind the scenes?

Like our Real Estate With Soul, The Podcast Page on Facebook

Follow Real Estate With Soul on Instagram